Why repeat-sale matters
Median sale price changes (the simplest measure of appreciation) can move because the mix of houses being sold changed, not because prices changed. A neighborhood whose median sale jumps from $300K to $400K may be appreciating, or it may just be selling more 4-bedroom houses this quarter. Repeat-sale indices control for that mix shift by looking only at the same houses over time — different transactions of the same property.
The FHFA HPI uses Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac transaction data, which covers the majority of conforming-loan home sales in the U.S.